Residential Property - 2008 Outlook

Residential Property - 2008 Outlook

Private Property South Africa
John Loos

We're into 2008, and as yet there is little sign of the 3-year+ broad slowdown in the

residential property market coming to an end. As things got worse in 2007, so

the talk regarding possible house price declines, rising bad debt in the housing

market, further upside risks to interest rates and prospects for a slowing

economy, and the negative impact of the National Credit Act, seemed to escalate.

Understandably, therefore, many property owners are concerned about where it's

all going to end. Human beings are often prone to doing their mental forecasting

by extrapolating a recent trend in a straight line into the future. Fortunately,

real life doesn't work in this manner. Rather, cycles are the order of the day,

and my view remains that 2008 is the year in which the cycle will bottom out and

begin to turn for the better.

But let's consider the risk of a crash in residential property. Well, firstly,

it may be comforting to know that residential property crashes are not common.

In fact, in over 40 years since the mid-1960s there has only been one, and that

was in the mid-1980s. Already, therefore, this would suggest that the chances

are slim.

Examining the graph below, which utilises Absa figures, one sees that since the

early-1970s it was only once in 1984/85 that SA experienced a nominal house

price decline. That was at the end of a major slump from a price inflation level

in excess of 40% in 1981, to deflation of -9% at a stage in 1985.

In real terms (deflating the house price index using the CPI), however, price

deflation is far more common. We saw a significant real house price decline in

the latter half of the 1970s just prior to the gold-boom-drive housing boom, the

slide of 84/85, and further gradual real decline over much of the 1990s to a low

in 1997.

Nevertheless, only the mid-1980s slump could possibly be a crash, so it is

worthwhile considering its causes.

The 1970s through to the early-1990s was a time of stagnating long term real

economic growth, as the country's political situation worsened and isolation and

boycotts started to bite; not to mention all sorts of structural rigidities

created by restrictive Apartheid legislation at the time. Making matters worse

was the onset of commodity price slump from the early-1980s.

If one were to calculate the sum of national GDP for 5-year periods, and then

calculate an average annual growth rate for these 5-year periods, thus cutting

out short term growth cycles; it is clear that from the early-1970s onward the

economy (all-important to the housing market performance) was becoming less and

less supportive to the property market in SA;

bar a very short period of spectacular economic growth during the gold price

boom of the early-1980s. Mining was a more key industry in SA in those days, and

it was little surprise, therefore, to see real GDP growth touch 6.6% in 1980

followed by 5.4% in 1981. In fact, in one particular quarter, year-on-year GDP

growth was close to 8%.

But it was all set to end in tears. The gold-boom-driven economic boom was

short-lived, proving to be a mere blip in a period of longer term growth

stagnation. The housing market began to slide after peaking in 1981, as the

economy slid into a recession in 1982/83. The stay of execution came towards

1984, with the economy experiencing a brief recovery, but by 1985 the negative

forces were far too great. Not only did GDP growth slip back into negative

territory in 1985, never to really impress again until the current decade, but

extreme interest rates also contributed to the end of that property party. From

1981 to 1985, prime rate had risen by 10.5 percentage points from 11% to 21.5%.

If that wasn't enough, confidence in the country was not exactly at an all time

high, as we headed nearer to Rubicon Speech time in the mid-1980s.

The series of interest rate hikes, coupled with extreme house price inflation,

had driven what is arguably the most important measure of affordability to its

worst levels on record by 1983.

The ratio I am referring to is the repayment instalment value on a 100% loan on

an average-priced house, expressed as a percentage of average income (in index

form). The graph below illustrates just how extremely this measure rose in the

early-80s boom.

Such levels of "in-affordability" could conceivably be maintained in a thriving

economy, but when stagnation returned following the brief growth boom, there was

only one way for real house prices and that was down.

And that was the environment which contributed to SA's only house price "crash"

in over 40 years.

How does the current environment compare? Well, glancing back at the first graph

showing real house price levels, you may be tempted to say that we're at far

more risk now than even at the peak of the 1980s boom; with real house rice

levels today far higher. And as at late last year, real house price levels were

still rising. Such an assertion would be too simplistic, however, as

sustainability of house price levels has everything to do with what the market

can afford and not what the price level is.

What the market can afford is determined by the combination of price, household

incomes, interest rates (for many households) and overall levels of


Going back to the affordability graph, which combines all of the above factors

except overall indebtedness, one will see that the recent boom has not seen

affordability deteriorate nearly as badly as the early '80s. The index

reflecting the average house price/average income ratio (more relevant for the

cash buyer) has shown a sharp increase since the late-1990s, but is still not

back at early-1980s levels. Due to the massive interest rate drops from 1998

onward, though, the index reflecting the ratio of repayment instalment value on

a 100% bond on an average priced house/average income has risen far less

extremely, and at a reading of 181 by the second quarter of last year was still

far lower than the 297 level reached at a stage in 1993. This containment of the

deterioration in affordability is not only due to interest rates but also in

part to strong household disposable income growth as a result of a strong

economic growth performance in the current decade, growth which has been far

more stable and seemingly sustainable than the boom/bust cycle of the


The continuation of this solid growth performance is crucial in staving off the

risks of collapse in the housing market. And risks there are. Globally, the

increasing possibility of a US recession looms large, while locally it is the

spectre of rising interest rates that threatens growth. If we were to go back to

interest rates near 20% (or even above), then indeed significant real house

price decline would most probably be on the cards. This would contribute

directly to the affordability deterioration for credit home buyers, as well as

indirectly by stifling job creation and income growth.

So one's view on whether housing is in trouble or not must essentially be driven

by your view on interest rates and economic growth, to name but the most

important 2 macro variables.

Based on our expectations for a fairly moderate growth slowdown in 2008, and, if

any, only limited further interest rate hiking, a deterioration in the local

economic environment to such an extent that it would precipitate SA's second

major housing market crash on record seems unlikely.

The long term economic growth graph indicates that SA has been on a long term

growth acceleration since the early-1990s. This was to be expected following the

end of restrictive Apartheid laws along with boycotts and sanctions, and the

country is still positively adjusting to the greater degree of economic freedom

that this political change brought about.

So, when we talk about real economic growth slowdown in 2008, we're talking

about to around 4% from an estimated 5% last year, hardly a train smash. Can the

US economy's woes drag SA's growth far lower than this? It isn't impossible, but

our view is that other regions of the world, most notably East Asia, are these

days better equipped to grow endogenously, with less dependence on the US, thus

providing an important growth engine whilst the US sorts out its issues.

Therefore, we anticipate a soft landing for both the global economy and

ourselves despite the US and its sub-prime and other challenges.

But even should the economic and interest rate moves in 2008 prove to be

moderate as we anticipate, you may well ask whether households can keep head

above water given their high levels of indebtedness?

If one were to emphasise the household debt-to-disposable income ratio as the

key predictor of a looming credit crunch, one may be tempted to raise the alarm

bells as this ratio heads towards 80%, now by far the highest ever.

But more important is the debt-service ratio, i.e. the debt servicing cost of

the total household sector debt burden (interest + capital)/household disposable

income. This ratio had risen to 10.4% by the third quarter of 2007. The rise

signifies greater stress for the household sector mounting, but by historic

cyclical increases it would not appear out of kilter. The previous 3 big

cyclical peaks saw debt service ratios of around 12% (ignoring the 14% blip in

1998 and the small rise in the abnormally good 2002 cycle).

So deterioration yes, but crisis no…based of course upon our moderate

macroeconomic assumptions.

What then do the bad debt figures for banks show to date? Once again, a fairly

moderate situation. DI500s unfortunately only go back as far as 2001. Special

mention mortgage loan accounts (accounts 1-2 months in arrears) rose through

2006/07 to near 3% of the total mortgage book for SA's banks, similar levels to

the peak of the 2002/03 cyclical deterioration (the abnormally good cycle).

Sub-standard loans (in arrears by 3-5 months) have risen to 1.5% of the total

book; doubtful loans (in arrears by 6-12 months) sit at 0.6%; and losses (more

than 12 months in arrears) measured 0.9% of the total book as at November 2007.

Some alarmists may want to emphasise that losses have risen by over 60% since

end-2006, and this is true. But off a low base that growth figure is largely

insignificant, and of course the total book has grown by near 30%, since then.

Therefore, while deteriorating, and I expect further deterioration in credit

quality during the first half of 2008, these ratios would hardly point to a

crisis situation in which a major portion of households would be having houses


Therefore, at current interest rate and economic growth levels, the key ratios

suggest that SA's residential property market is in far better shape than was

the case in the mid-1980s.

There are no guarantees that things can't still go pear-shaped, should the

interest rate and economic growth environment turn dramatically for the worse;

as the risks are always there. But based on our forecasts of a mild growth

slowdown to 4% in 2008, and interest rates going into a sideways trend very

soon, disaster should be avoided.


This doesn't mean the end of the road for market weakening just yet. I

believe we should prepare ourselves for a dip into single-digit year-on-year

house price inflation within the next few months, and it is conceivable that

house price inflation could dip below a resurgent CPI inflation rate briefly in

the near future, indicating some real house price decline.

But later in 2008, I remain of the view that we will see the turning point in

the market, and a resumption of real house price inflation to even higher

levels. As soon as interest rates level out, we can expect to see some recovery

in growth in new mortgage loans granted (which showed negative growth in the

third quarter of 2007), a good indicator of residential demand. This is

anticipated during the second quarter. This event normally coincides with an

upturn in month-on-month house price inflation, and with a considerable lag and

turn in year-on-year house price inflation.


Found this content useful?

Get the best of Private Property's latest news and advice delivered straight to your inbox each week

Related Articles

Add value to your home with the right choice of fireplace
Latest trends in fireplaces that will warm your home and add value to your property.
Tips for heating your home and saving money
Saving electricity makes excellent financial sense, and with winter coming up it pays to look at ways of warming your home that will save money in the process.
Safety and security tips for agents
Estate agents need to be alert and aware of the risks involved in showing properties and meeting new clients.
Gas installations – what homeowners need to know
All gas installations need certificates of compliance issued by certified installers.